“The man
whose name was known for courage, the Great leader, resolute in his helmet,
answered in return: ‘We are retainers, from Hygelac’s band. Beowulf is my
name.’” This introductory declaration about Beowulf by Beowulf himself
describes his struggle to build up and form the reputation that he has, gaining
it through his great deeds in life. Beowulf describes a hero and his
epic journey of his life through his confidence, fidelity, valor, and
determination. With Beowulf depicting an idol for every reader since
traditional literary time period, the concept of heroism hasn’t changed much
over time. Beatrice Prior, “heroic” protagonist of Divergent by Veronica
Roth, faces comparable difficulties and victories in life as of Beowulf, but
the readers’ perception towards the theme of the book or the character changes
because of the feminist narration and a female hero.
A
propensity of readers is to analyze a book or a work of art and to scrutinize,
and sometimes even criticize the author or the artist’s biographical background
and beliefs and then form judgments on their work based on it. But in Beowulf’s
case, readers are restricted because the author is unknown. Its author uses
literary techniques such as foreshadowing, metaphors, similes, irony,
hyperbole, personification, etc and conveys them through syntax and diction
that is grandiose, formal, and exaggerated – hyperbole. A monster, Grendel, is
given a name and characteristics as of a human being and presented to the
audience as a terrifying enemy and obstacle for Beowulf to overcome. Beowulf is
depicted to be a confident, fearless, and generous character, who has unstinted
love for his people and willing to risk and sacrifice his life for them. The
grandiose diction allows the author to bring the level of intensity and courage
of Beowulf to an elevated level, almost impossible to achieve by a normal
individual. With Beowulf becoming an icon of heroism for authors of all periods
of time, authors have now found a new approach for characteristics and actions of
a hero.
“True
heroism is remarkably sober, very undramatic. It is not the urge to surpass all
others at whatever cost, but the urge to serve others at whatever cost.”1 Contemporary
readers have developed this
perception towards the basic concept of heroism: it is merely a fight of good
vs. evil and heroism is the victory of good over evil. It allows the readers to
deem that heroes are authentic because they can also exist in real life.
Beatrice (“Tris”) Prior is a paragon of a contemporary hero. She’s strong,
confident, and an independent woman who lives not only for herself but also for
the community around her. But unlike traditional heroes, such as Beowulf,
authors characterize modern heroes with a personal fight that they have to
overcome without external help – an internal conflict. Beowulf had no internal
conflict, allowing him to make a decision solely based his instincts and
self-confidence. But for Tris, her internal conflict was to choose a faction
that both contented her parents and herself. Throughout the entire book or even
series, Tris went through an epic journey of discovering who she truly is while
fighting the external forces such as society and authority. With Tris becoming
a revolutionary figure, readers get inspiration to start a movement. Also with
modern heroes, as said in the quote, they’re sober – so don’t have attitude or
arrogance about their abilities or characteristics. Because of this, readers
might consider Beowulf to be quite arrogant as he said that he’ll fight the
monster – even naked. With readers’ perception changing, the future generation
heroes might even seem more realistic than those as of now.
Although
Beowulf and Tris seem to be differentiated by the time period and the literary
techniques used in both pieces of literature, they do have many similarities as
well. Obviously since both the characters are heroes, they both have an enemy,
an antagonist – someone or something they need to fight. Even though they’re
heroes, they still need someone to rely on, someone to trust. Beowulf needed
Hrothgar to support his followers and his people if something were to happen to
him. Tris, even though had her entire family, needed someone to take care of
them and so had Four to do it. But female heroes are still not as prominent as
male. According to a CNN news report, young adult literature focuses more on
emotions – to sadden, to shock, or to awaken – and on characteristics of the
plot, setting, and characters. And authors find their ability to do it on a
greater extent with men protagonists than with women. Since female characters
face more and complex problems in life than male characters do, Beowulf
would’ve been more complex and convoluted of an epic if told by a feminist
perspective. The story would be less realistic if Beowulf were to be
told in a feminist perspective because women were viewed to be caring, loving,
and soft natured to be fighting a villain. And so, the enemy for a woman
protagonist is generally weaker than a man’s. Basically, a feminist perspective
would take an essence of Beowulf and his heroic abilities out of the story.
A hero
doesn’t have to be a fictional character who’s smart, talented, strong, good looking, and all those qualities
merged into one – but only has to be kind hearted and courageous enough to
start a movement. Even though both Tris and Beowulf had their own abilities
that set them apart from a normal crowd, they only had the courage to stand up
against the wrong – Beowulf against Grendel and Tris against authority – that
made them heroes. This major quality gives the readers hope and inspiration
that even they can be heroes. A quote from Tris’s faction, Dauntless, that
perfectly captures this idea, is: “We believe in ordinary acts of bravery in
the courage that drives one person to stand up for another.”
1 A quote by Arthur Ashe
Great essay, Naomi. I really like the way you introduced the topic of the piece in you r thesis statement! I am very impressed! Don't be surprised if you see your essay up on the board tomorrow in class! ;)
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for all your appreciation Stevie!
DeleteHey Naiomi(:
ReplyDeleteI really liked your introductory paragraph; you did a good job with your thesis statement because you covered many topics through out the essay. I loved how your essay was structured and the vocabulary you used!
-Jisu
Good Job! (:
Thanks Jisu for always giving me advice and ideas for my betterment. Thanks again
DeleteI think that your thesis is very well written and straightforward, but I also think that when you wrote your body paragraphs you could have related back to your thesis directly. Sometimes you went off on a tangent, but overall your essay is really good. A little more directness throughout the rest of your essay and it will be a perfect paper!
ReplyDeleteThank you Courtney for the honest advice and I completely agree with you and I definitely will keep it in mind to make it better. Thanks again!!
DeleteThe thesis of your essay is "With Beowulf depicting an idol for every reader since traditional literary time period, the concept of heroism hasn’t changed much over time." Your essay provided a solid job in addressing the prompt specifically with comparing Beowulf to a modern hero, describing lit. techniques used to depict those contrasts, and how telling the reader how Beowulf would change if told through a feminist perspective. An awesome point you made was that in future literature, the modern hero of said time period is going to be even more realistic now which got me thinking that the hero wil only evolve even more with time. However, the lit. techniques used in your first body paragraph were a bit random, sort of thrown at the reader. You should've incorporated them into your thesis somehow and say how that affects the contrasts of Beowulf and Tris and depictions of what the hero is. Also, your fourth paragraph contained many ideas that could've been executed in a more organized fashion, jumping from similarities, to differences, to the female perspective. There was a bit too much there. Other than that, good job Naiomi! (Happy Birthday, yet again(: )
ReplyDeleteThanks Edgar for the advice, and yeah I definitely should have done more with the lit techniques.. thanks again Edgar for your honest opinion and also, the birthday wish!!
DeleteI think you did a really good job with your essay, and with incorporating both of the prompts instead of doing just one. You explained very clearly the difference between Divergent & Beowulf based off of one hero being female, and it made sense. Nice job.
ReplyDeleteThanks Lillie so much for appreciation!
ReplyDelete